Mairin Mitchell’s and Walter Starkie’s Divergent(?) Images of Pre-War Spain (1934-1936)

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.28914/Atlantis-2025-47.2.7

Keywords:

Spanish Civil War, Walter Starkie, Mairin Mitchell, Hiberno-Spanish relations

Abstract

Despite the neighbouring, though politically contentious, relationship between Ireland and Britain over centuries, Irish writers have cultivated a singular image of Spain that veers away from the British Romantic construct of the country in general and the Spanish conflict in particular, an image that has customarily been overlooked although the Spanish Civil War, its history, its aftermath and its international implications have always held a deep fascination for Irish writers. This article revolves around the image of Spain as portrayed by two Irish authors who travelled in Spain on the verge of the conflict and who held divergent political stances: Walter Starkie (1894-1976), who supported the nationalist cause, and Mairin Mitchell (1895-1986), who had a pro-left ideology. Through the exploration of Starkie’s and Mitchell’s travelogues, lectures, newspaper articles and personal letters, this article will examine the extent to which these two positions are at odds and the reasons behind these differences.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Author Biography

Verónica Membrive, Universidad de Almería

Verónica Membrive completed her Ph.D. at the University of Almería in 2017. Her research focuses on Irish literature, with a particular emphasis on Hiberno-Spanish cultural relations. She has published research articles on Walter Starkie, Kate O’Brien, Pearse Hutchison, Mairin Mitchell, and F.D. Sheridan, and their travels in Spain. She is the co-editor of A Nation, Not a Parish: The Homewheres and Elsewheres of 1930s Irish Culture (Peter Lang, 2024) and Trauma, Memory and Silence in Contemporary Irish Culture (Routledge, 2023). She received the International George Campbell Award for her research on Hiberno-Spanish cultural relations (University of Málaga, 2018). She has served as managing editor of Estudios Irlandeses (2019-2021) and currently holds the same position at Odisea.

References

ARMENDÁRIZ, Xabier. 2022. Mairin Mitchell: La cronista irlandesa de los vascos. Bizkaia Euskal Herria Museoa.

BLANTON, Casey. 2002. Travel Writing: The Self and the World. East Sussex, UK: Psychology Press.

BELL, J. Bowyer. 1969. “Ireland and the Spanish Civil War, 1936-1939.” Studia Hibernica 9: 137–63.

BRADY, Deirdre F. 2021. Literary Coteries and the Irish Women Writers' Club (1933-1958). Vol 87. Oxford: Oxford UP.

BROWN, Terence. 1981. Ireland: A Social and Cultural History. 1922-79. Glasgow: Fontana Paperbacks.

CASEY, Maurice. 2018. Radicalising the Irish Diaspora. Irish Diaspora Histories Network (blog) [Accessed July 06, 2023]

CULLEN, Niall. 2021. “‘Oh Ireland! What a Disappointment You Have Been to the Basque People’: Irish Non-Intervention in the Spanish Civil War.” Society 58 (2): 104–11.

DE ARCOS, Marina Pérez. 2021. “Education, Intelligence and Cultural Diplomacy at the British Council in Madrid, 1940–1941. Part 1: Founding a School in Troubled Times.” Bulletin of Spanish Studies 98 (4): 527–55.

—. 2021. “Education, Intelligence and Cultural Diplomacy at the British Council in Madrid, 1940–1941. Part 2: Shock Troops in the War of Ideas.” Bulletin of Spanish Studies 98 (5): 707–38.

Ensayos hispano-ingleses: homenaje a Walter Starkie. 1948. Barcelona: José Janés.

GOLDSTONE, Katrina. 2020. Irish Writers and the Thirties: Art, Exile and War. Vol 99. New York: Routledge.

HEINZ, Sarah. 2012. “From Utopia to Heterotopia: Irish Writers Narrating the Spanish Civil War.” In Huber, Mayer and Novak 2012, 93-104.

HUBER, Werner, Sandra Mayer and Julia Novak, eds. 2012. Ireland in/and Europe: Cross-Currents and Exchanges. Irish Studies in Europe Vol 4. Trier: WVT.

HURTLEY, Jacqueline. 2005. “Wandering Between the Wars: Walter Starkie’s Di/Visions.” In Tazón Salas and Carrera Suárez 2005, 51-62.

—. 2010. Un auténtico amigo de España: el profesor Walter Starkie y los primeros años del British Council en España. Madrid: British Council.

—. 2013. Walter Starkie 1894-1976: An Odyssey. Dublin: Four Courts Press.

KEANE, Damien. 2015. Ireland and the Problem of Information: Irish Writing, Radio, Late Modernist Communication. University Park, PA: Penn State Press.

KLAUS, H. Gustav. 1991. “‘The Sore Frailty of This Lasting Cause’: Some Celtic Versions of Spanish Civil War Poetry.” Irish University Review 21 (2): 268–84.

MACDIARMADA, Mary. 2020. Art O’Brien and Irish Nationalism in London, 1900-1925. Dublin: Four Courts Press.

MCCREANOR, Kyle. 2022. “Ireland, the Basques and the Spanish Civil War.” Irish Historical Studies 46 (169): 136–54.

MCGARRY, Fearghal. 2001. “Ireland and the Spanish Civil War.” History Ireland 9 (3): 35–40.

—. 2002. “Irish Newspapers and the Spanish Civil War.” Irish Historical Studies 33 (129): 68–90.

—. 2008. Eoin O’Duffy: A Self-Made Hero. Oxford: Oxford UP.

MCLOUGHLIN, Barry and Emmet O’Connor. 2020. “In Spanish Trenches”: The Mind and Deeds of the Irish Who Fought for the Republic in the Spanish Civil War. Dublin: University College Dublin.

MITCHELL, David J. 2004. Travellers in Spain. Fuengirola: Santana Classics.

MITCHELL, Mairin. 1932. “A Little Ireland at the Pyrenees.” Irish Press, October 18, 6.

—. 1933. “There Is Peace in the World Too.” Irish Press, April 01, 8.

—. 1934. “Catalonia and Her People.” Irish Press, October 17, 6.

—. 1934. Letter to Hanna Seehy-Skeffington. May 28. MS 33,607. National Library of Ireland.

—. 1935. Letter to Hanna Seehy-Skeffington. June 01. MS 33,607. National Library of Ireland.

—. 1935. Letter to Hanna Seehy-Skeffington. December 16. MS 33,607. National Library of Ireland.

—. 1935. Traveller in Time. London: Sheed & Ward.

—. 1936. Letter to Hanna Seehy-Skeffington. March 07. MS 33,607. National Library of Ireland.

—. 1936. Letter to Hanna Seehy-Skeffington. March 13. MS 33,607. National Library of Ireland.

—. 1936. Letter to Hanna Seehy-Skeffington. March 14. MS 33,607. National Library of Ireland.

—. 1936. Letter to Hanna Seehy-Skeffington. May 14. MS 33,607. National Library of Ireland.

—. 1936. Letter to Hanna Seehy-Skeffington. August 11. MS 33,607. National Library of Ireland.

—. 1936. Letter to Hanna Seehy-Skeffington. September 26. MS 33,607. National Library of Ireland.

—. 1936. Letter to Hanna Seehy-Skeffington. September 29. MS 33,607. National Library of Ireland.

—. 1936. Letter to Hanna Seehy-Skeffington. September 30. MS 33,607. National Library of Ireland.

—. 1937. Letter to Hanna Seehy-Skeffington. March 02. MS 33,607. National Library of Ireland.

—. 1937. Letter to Hanna Seehy-Skeffington. May 19. MS 33,607. National Library of Ireland.

—. 1937. Letter to Hanna Seehy-Skeffington. May 26. MS 33,607. National Library of Ireland.

—. 1937. Storm over Spain. London: Secker & Warburg.

MITTERMAIER, Ute Anna. 2017. Images of Spain in Irish Literature, 1922-1975. Berlin: Peter Lang Limited, International Academic Publishers, 2017.

MORILLAS VENTURA, Enriqueta. 1997. “Las reflexiones de Lino Novás Calvo (II).” Anales de Literatura Hispanoamericana 26 (2): 173–86.

NELSON, Cary. 2013. Revolutionary Memory: Recovering the Poetry of the American Left. New York: Routledge.

O’BRIEN, Mark. 2017. “‘In War-torn Spain’: The Politics of Irish Press Coverage of the Spanish Civil War.” Media, War & Conflict 10 (3): 345–58.

O’CONNOR, Emmet. 2008. “Identity and Self-representation in Irish Communism.” Socialist History 34: 36–51.

ORWELL, George. 1968. “Review Storm over Spain by Mairin Mitchell.” The Collected Essays, Journalism and Letters of George Orwell: An Age like This, 1920-1940. London: Secker & Warburg.

PAYNE, Stanley G. 2011. Spain: A Unique History. Madison: University of Wisconsin.

PRAZ, Mario. 1926. Peninsula Pentagonale: Unromantic Spain. New York: A. A. Knopf.

PRESTON, Paul. The Spanish Civil War: Reaction, Revolution and Revenge. New York: Norton, 2006.

SEEHY-SKEFFINGTON, Owen. 1936. “A Foreign Commentary.” Ireland Today, 1 (4): 4-8.

STARKIE, Walter. 1928. “Whither Is Ireland Heading - Is It Fascism? Thought on the Irish Free State.” The International Centre of Fascist Studies and Its Yearbook - Survey of Fascism 1928. Lausanne: Ernest Benn Ltd.

—. 1934. Spanish Raggle-Taggle. Adventures with a Fiddle in North Spain. London: Murray.

—. 1936. Don Gypsy. Adventures with a Fiddle in Barbary, Andalusia and La Mancha. London: Butler & Tanner Ltd.

—. 1937. “Irish Links with Spain.” Irish Independent, March 05, 10.

—. 1937. “Leader Reds. The Position in Spain.” Irish Independent, March 06, 11.

—. 1938. “Fear of War.” Irish Independent, February 19, 12.

—. 1938. The Waveless Plain: An Italian Autobiography. London: Butler & Tanner Ltd.

—. 1940. Letter to Lord Lloyd. September 17, TNA, BW, 56/2.

—.1963. Scholars and Gypsies: An Autobiography. London: Murray.

STRADLING, Robert A. 1999. The Irish and the Spanish Civil War, 1936-39: Crusades in Conflict. Manchester, UK: Manchester UP.

TAZÓN SALAS, Juan E. and Isabel Carrera Suárez, eds. 2005. Post/Imperial Encounters: Anglo-Hispanic Cultural Relations. Amsterdam: Rodopi

TREGLOWN, Jeremy. 2013. Franco's Crypt: Spanish Culture and Memory since 1936. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux.

“Women in the News: Mairin Mitchell in Spain.” 1936. Irish Press, May 27, 5.

Downloads

Published

2025-12-09

How to Cite

Membrive, V. (2025). Mairin Mitchell’s and Walter Starkie’s Divergent(?) Images of Pre-War Spain (1934-1936). Atlantis. Journal of the Spanish Association for Anglo-American Studies. https://doi.org/10.28914/Atlantis-2025-47.2.7

Issue

Section

Articles

Funding data